|
Question
|
ZachariahSalazarRKC: April 30 2006
|
|
Pavel....
|
|
How do I submit an article for consideration? thanks zachariah salazar
AFPtraining@Gmail.com
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 01 2006
|
|
Zachariah,
Send it on to me - breakingstrength@yahoo.com
I am assisting in the editing of the articles submitted - please be sure to include a bio and any pictures you think might be helpful.
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
eddie99: April 30 2006
|
|
Steve C, Pavel, Mike M, Steve M or other SRKC...Training (Bone cancer)
|
|
Hi all,
I sent a previous post at http://forum.dragondoor.com/training/message/400950%5C and http://forum.dragondoor.com/training/message/400951%5C
Any insight or advice from a SRKC would be great! Thanks for all your help guys!
Eddie
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 01 2006
|
|
Eddie,
This is a complicated issue - you need to have a Dr.'s clearance before you do much of anything.
the Dr. will have recommendations re: exercise - also check with and get input from a good physical therapist who can work with the Dr. to guide and assist in the process.
KBs may or may not be appropriate.
Best of luck
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
SSGGLASS: May 02 2006
|
|
Need advice on Nail bending, all input welcome
|
|
I am highly interested in the art of steel bending and scrolling, and it was suggested i start with Iron Minds bag of nails. They have 5 levels listed, where should i begin? how often should a person work this skill? Who here bends steel, and what recommendations do you have? Thanks!
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 02 2006
|
|
SSGGLASS,
Jim's recommendations are good - Eric Goodfrey's page and the gripboard are good places to start.
go slower than you think you should - take time bending for some volume at lighter nails before you go up to high in difficulty.
I do like the IM bag of nails but would at least order the IM blue pads to use for padding.
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
cannavaro: May 02 2006
|
|
Tension vs Tightness?
|
|
I recently posted this question on the Z forum but as its quiet on there I thought Id put it on here for more exposure- Frankie pls ignore!
When I see programs about Oriental Chi Masters they often have soft, sometimes slightly flabby muscles yet they pull off amazing feats of strength. (I saw one 'untoned' guy pull a landrover with a harness while walking on eggs that didnt break!)
Then I read about muscle tone being residual myogenic tension in the muscle. Surely the point of strength training is to become as strong as possible with minimum effort? And surely you would want to feel as light and relaxed as possible when not training? I see the world Girevoy sport champion on Cotters DVD lifting a 32kg KB with his little finger (!) and he is not especially- and I hate the word- toned.
So if you practise high tension strength techniques such as Pavels PTP are you not becoming tense?
And as many peoples number one goal is to become 'toned' is there a pay off btwn myogenic tension and a relaxed, efficient musculature?
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 02 2006
|
|
If you have ever seen Steve Cotter, Pavel, Bud Jefferies and others drop into a split and/or throw punches you wouldn't have a question.
If all you do is practice tension - you will become tight -
If you mix in mobility and relaxation drills (superjoints, fast and loose) you will be able to effeciently shift from tension to relaxation.
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
bobptz: May 14 2006
|
|
PTP-Bear did not work for me. Why?
|
|
I started PTP-BEAR midle of November 2005. I did not do it strictly by the book. ie I also did 20 rep squat, I also tried to alternate the presses with BenchPress, Dips, Military press, ChinUps. (it is all in my training log)
The results are redicilous.
I did manage to increase my 20 rep squat from 80 kgrs to 95 kgrs. This seems to be my only improvement. And it is not PTP.
My DL seemed to improve, but this is very natural, since I never DeadLifted before. I rapidly went up to 125 kgrs (5 reps) in December 2005. I never made it past that.
My chinups are exactly the same as they were 5 months ago. My bices are 39 cm. The same it was before I started PTP. And they were 41 cm last year! I am completely lost here.
Last year I could Bench Press 110 kgr (1RM). Now I am afraid to try even with 100 kgr.
I have a lot of faith in PTP. I helped newbies develop bodies rapidly with sets of 5. Why can't I help myself?
I started serious working out with weights 3 years ago and had great improvements in the first 2 years. This last one was the most counterproductive. I switched to PTP on November when I saw I was stuck with my old BB methods. I was not the most dedicated person this year. I used to go out a lot, stay up until late (4-5:00 am) up until February. I was much beter afterwards. I eat VERY healthy. I did gain 3-4 kgrs since September, so I did eat enough.
I know it is very difficult to diagnose a problem over the net. If I look elsewhere for advice they will laugh at the system I followed and they will direct me to the old methods.
Bob
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 14 2006
|
|
Bob,
Switching to a PTP cycle for a month would be a good idea.
I looked at your training log and there is only one entry - correct me if I am wrong...
You have down increasing your bench as one of your goals but it isn't mentioned in your training log entry.
The volume and intesity of the 6 week Super Squats program - if done correctly - should be all you can handle for your legs.
The Bear is - if I remember correctly - 90% of 5 rm - then 80% of 5 rm - then 70% of 5 rm for between 10 - 20 sets (1-2 minutes rest between sets) - if your training log entry is correct then your were only doing 6-7 additional sets and at a lower percentage (not by much but...)
Do the PTP program by the letter for a month - then take a back off week and then redesign your bear program by the letter and go again...
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
bobptz: May 14 2006
|
|
PTP-Bear did not work for me. Why?
|
|
I started PTP-BEAR midle of November 2005. I did not do it strictly by the book. ie I also did 20 rep squat, I also tried to alternate the presses with BenchPress, Dips, Military press, ChinUps. (it is all in my training log)
The results are redicilous.
I did manage to increase my 20 rep squat from 80 kgrs to 95 kgrs. This seems to be my only improvement. And it is not PTP.
My DL seemed to improve, but this is very natural, since I never DeadLifted before. I rapidly went up to 125 kgrs (5 reps) in December 2005. I never made it past that.
My chinups are exactly the same as they were 5 months ago. My bices are 39 cm. The same it was before I started PTP. And they were 41 cm last year! I am completely lost here.
Last year I could Bench Press 110 kgr (1RM). Now I am afraid to try even with 100 kgr.
I have a lot of faith in PTP. I helped newbies develop bodies rapidly with sets of 5. Why can't I help myself?
I started serious working out with weights 3 years ago and had great improvements in the first 2 years. This last one was the most counterproductive. I switched to PTP on November when I saw I was stuck with my old BB methods. I was not the most dedicated person this year. I used to go out a lot, stay up until late (4-5:00 am) up until February. I was much beter afterwards. I eat VERY healthy. I did gain 3-4 kgrs since September, so I did eat enough.
I know it is very difficult to diagnose a problem over the net. If I look elsewhere for advice they will laugh at the system I followed and they will direct me to the old methods.
Bob
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 15 2006
|
|
Bob,
You spent the past few months never having a back off week and did not cycle your weights.
Your training varied from everyday to as much as 10 days between sessions at times.
Do a PTP cycle -
Begin at 85kg for the DL (2nd set -10%)- add 2.5kgs per workout
Begin at 55kg for the bench - (2nd set -10%)- add 2.5kgs per workout
develop a similar starting weight for your chin-ups
This should last (if lifting 5 days per week) 12 or so workouts - then have a couple of easy days and cycle back down to 5 kgs above your starting weights for the previous cycle.
After 2 PTP cycles - take a back off week - only three easy workouts in the week - then start again.
Then if you wanted to do a 20 rep squat cycle - do the 20 reps squats for 4-6 weeks as outlined in the book - Super Squats.
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
bobptz: May 14 2006
|
|
PTP-Bear did not work for me. Why?
|
|
I started PTP-BEAR midle of November 2005. I did not do it strictly by the book. ie I also did 20 rep squat, I also tried to alternate the presses with BenchPress, Dips, Military press, ChinUps. (it is all in my training log)
The results are redicilous.
I did manage to increase my 20 rep squat from 80 kgrs to 95 kgrs. This seems to be my only improvement. And it is not PTP.
My DL seemed to improve, but this is very natural, since I never DeadLifted before. I rapidly went up to 125 kgrs (5 reps) in December 2005. I never made it past that.
My chinups are exactly the same as they were 5 months ago. My bices are 39 cm. The same it was before I started PTP. And they were 41 cm last year! I am completely lost here.
Last year I could Bench Press 110 kgr (1RM). Now I am afraid to try even with 100 kgr.
I have a lot of faith in PTP. I helped newbies develop bodies rapidly with sets of 5. Why can't I help myself?
I started serious working out with weights 3 years ago and had great improvements in the first 2 years. This last one was the most counterproductive. I switched to PTP on November when I saw I was stuck with my old BB methods. I was not the most dedicated person this year. I used to go out a lot, stay up until late (4-5:00 am) up until February. I was much beter afterwards. I eat VERY healthy. I did gain 3-4 kgrs since September, so I did eat enough.
I know it is very difficult to diagnose a problem over the net. If I look elsewhere for advice they will laugh at the system I followed and they will direct me to the old methods.
Bob
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 15 2006
|
|
Bob,
Then start low and add 5kg each workout - 5kg x 12sessions = 60kg
The idea of starting low and ending at new level is the idea - I was looking at your training log and for the bench you have been stuck at the same level for a while - 83-85kg for your work sets. Time to mix it up - start low - finish high.
So readjust the starting weights to give yourself a 5kg or so PR at the end of the cycles - just keep with the idea.
Time spent on lower weights to groove form is never wasted - You have ONLY been deadlifting for 5 months - Professional lifters spend YEARS constantly refining their form and learning to perform the same lift - only better. You do not have it mastered after 5 months.
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
bobptz: May 14 2006
|
|
PTP-Bear did not work for me. Why?
|
|
I started PTP-BEAR midle of November 2005. I did not do it strictly by the book. ie I also did 20 rep squat, I also tried to alternate the presses with BenchPress, Dips, Military press, ChinUps. (it is all in my training log)
The results are redicilous.
I did manage to increase my 20 rep squat from 80 kgrs to 95 kgrs. This seems to be my only improvement. And it is not PTP.
My DL seemed to improve, but this is very natural, since I never DeadLifted before. I rapidly went up to 125 kgrs (5 reps) in December 2005. I never made it past that.
My chinups are exactly the same as they were 5 months ago. My bices are 39 cm. The same it was before I started PTP. And they were 41 cm last year! I am completely lost here.
Last year I could Bench Press 110 kgr (1RM). Now I am afraid to try even with 100 kgr.
I have a lot of faith in PTP. I helped newbies develop bodies rapidly with sets of 5. Why can't I help myself?
I started serious working out with weights 3 years ago and had great improvements in the first 2 years. This last one was the most counterproductive. I switched to PTP on November when I saw I was stuck with my old BB methods. I was not the most dedicated person this year. I used to go out a lot, stay up until late (4-5:00 am) up until February. I was much beter afterwards. I eat VERY healthy. I did gain 3-4 kgrs since September, so I did eat enough.
I know it is very difficult to diagnose a problem over the net. If I look elsewhere for advice they will laugh at the system I followed and they will direct me to the old methods.
Bob
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 15 2006
|
|
Bob,
By the end of your second cycle you will exceed your previous PR - make haste slowly!
This will give you time to groove form and work with confidence - establishing the tension techniques etc...
If you can only make 5kg jumps then yes - go with the step cycle - yet another reason to start low with the weights.
Yes missing 10 days at a time - having physiotherapy etc...will all detract from the momentum of a consistant training routine. yet another reason to start light - get used to training 5 days a week and let the intensity build as you go.
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
bobptz: May 14 2006
|
|
PTP-Bear did not work for me. Why?
|
|
I started PTP-BEAR midle of November 2005. I did not do it strictly by the book. ie I also did 20 rep squat, I also tried to alternate the presses with BenchPress, Dips, Military press, ChinUps. (it is all in my training log)
The results are redicilous.
I did manage to increase my 20 rep squat from 80 kgrs to 95 kgrs. This seems to be my only improvement. And it is not PTP.
My DL seemed to improve, but this is very natural, since I never DeadLifted before. I rapidly went up to 125 kgrs (5 reps) in December 2005. I never made it past that.
My chinups are exactly the same as they were 5 months ago. My bices are 39 cm. The same it was before I started PTP. And they were 41 cm last year! I am completely lost here.
Last year I could Bench Press 110 kgr (1RM). Now I am afraid to try even with 100 kgr.
I have a lot of faith in PTP. I helped newbies develop bodies rapidly with sets of 5. Why can't I help myself?
I started serious working out with weights 3 years ago and had great improvements in the first 2 years. This last one was the most counterproductive. I switched to PTP on November when I saw I was stuck with my old BB methods. I was not the most dedicated person this year. I used to go out a lot, stay up until late (4-5:00 am) up until February. I was much beter afterwards. I eat VERY healthy. I did gain 3-4 kgrs since September, so I did eat enough.
I know it is very difficult to diagnose a problem over the net. If I look elsewhere for advice they will laugh at the system I followed and they will direct me to the old methods.
Bob
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 14 2006
|
|
Bob,
If you only increased your 20 rep squat by 15kg since November - you did not push the squats enough and didn't follow the 20 rep program.
You tried to mix too many exercises in the Bear mix - stick to the basics - make regular increases in your weights - if you cannot you are starting at too high a weight.
Start over and stick to the program - DL + Bench and add in some chins if you want.
Or
Only do the 20 rep squat program as outlined in the book Super Squats.
JMO
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
BullGooseLooney: May 17 2006
|
|
PLEASE HELP ME!!!!!!!!!!!
|
|
My high-school swimming career is in danger; I am too big.
Currently I am 17 just finished my junior year, 5' 8.5'' and 170 pounds when I wake up in the morning!
I would like to get myself down to 155 pounds while maintaing (or increasing) strength and still improve swimming. This is muscle weight I am talking about, from looking at myself I think I am about 10% BF, I don't care about body fat I need to drop some muscle. I have no idea what to do to accomplish these goals with diet or weight training. I am planning on doing this with a combination of KB work, overhead squats, and front squats, good idea? With all this I will be swimming 2-3 hours mon-sat. I know if I just drop some weight I will get faster even if I get weaker, currently in practice it is tough to pace 100's on 60 sec while 3 months ago, and 8 pounds ago, I could do these on 56 sec. I have no idea what to do with diet, relative strength athletes please provide some help.
PLEASE HELP ME
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 18 2006
|
|
Sorry for the Monopoly reference but stop and do not listen to those telling you to lose muscle and weight -
Get yourself to a coach, physician, and/or trainer who works with athletes and get an evaluation.
your times could change due to any number of things... stress, overtraining, diet, etc....
Lighter and weaker will be slower - know what you need to change and how to do it right.
Brett
Post back with any questions.
|
|
|
|
Question
|
BullGooseLooney: May 17 2006
|
|
PLEASE HELP ME!!!!!!!!!!!
|
|
My high-school swimming career is in danger; I am too big.
Currently I am 17 just finished my junior year, 5' 8.5'' and 170 pounds when I wake up in the morning!
I would like to get myself down to 155 pounds while maintaing (or increasing) strength and still improve swimming. This is muscle weight I am talking about, from looking at myself I think I am about 10% BF, I don't care about body fat I need to drop some muscle. I have no idea what to do to accomplish these goals with diet or weight training. I am planning on doing this with a combination of KB work, overhead squats, and front squats, good idea? With all this I will be swimming 2-3 hours mon-sat. I know if I just drop some weight I will get faster even if I get weaker, currently in practice it is tough to pace 100's on 60 sec while 3 months ago, and 8 pounds ago, I could do these on 56 sec. I have no idea what to do with diet, relative strength athletes please provide some help.
PLEASE HELP ME
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 18 2006
|
|
"Who knows why he needs it?"
Exactly the point - a 17 year old who doesn't know why or how to lose weight when he may or may not in fact need to do so is handed information - are you prepared to take responsibility for how that information is applied?
This is a case for referral to a professional that can appropriately assess the needs of this person.
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
BullGooseLooney: May 17 2006
|
|
PLEASE HELP ME!!!!!!!!!!!
|
|
My high-school swimming career is in danger; I am too big.
Currently I am 17 just finished my junior year, 5' 8.5'' and 170 pounds when I wake up in the morning!
I would like to get myself down to 155 pounds while maintaing (or increasing) strength and still improve swimming. This is muscle weight I am talking about, from looking at myself I think I am about 10% BF, I don't care about body fat I need to drop some muscle. I have no idea what to do to accomplish these goals with diet or weight training. I am planning on doing this with a combination of KB work, overhead squats, and front squats, good idea? With all this I will be swimming 2-3 hours mon-sat. I know if I just drop some weight I will get faster even if I get weaker, currently in practice it is tough to pace 100's on 60 sec while 3 months ago, and 8 pounds ago, I could do these on 56 sec. I have no idea what to do with diet, relative strength athletes please provide some help.
PLEASE HELP ME
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 18 2006
|
|
If at 5'8" and 170 you are one of the largest swimmers he has worked with - your coach has worked with some very small athletes.
Consult with the strength coach, and athletic trainer if available.
Keep us posted
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
BullGooseLooney: May 17 2006
|
|
PLEASE HELP ME!!!!!!!!!!!
|
|
My high-school swimming career is in danger; I am too big.
Currently I am 17 just finished my junior year, 5' 8.5'' and 170 pounds when I wake up in the morning!
I would like to get myself down to 155 pounds while maintaing (or increasing) strength and still improve swimming. This is muscle weight I am talking about, from looking at myself I think I am about 10% BF, I don't care about body fat I need to drop some muscle. I have no idea what to do to accomplish these goals with diet or weight training. I am planning on doing this with a combination of KB work, overhead squats, and front squats, good idea? With all this I will be swimming 2-3 hours mon-sat. I know if I just drop some weight I will get faster even if I get weaker, currently in practice it is tough to pace 100's on 60 sec while 3 months ago, and 8 pounds ago, I could do these on 56 sec. I have no idea what to do with diet, relative strength athletes please provide some help.
PLEASE HELP ME
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 18 2006
|
|
do you have a coach? or coaches? have you consulted your parents, coaches, trainers (your high school may have or have access to an Athletic Trainer... Get good advice from professionals that can help you.
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
MrMyofibrillar: May 17 2006
|
|
Injury, but otherwise swell time at the gym (long)
|
|
I've been banging up my shoulders with highly frequent sessions of weighted dips and weighted chins. I've been going to the gym every 8-12 hours and alternating working these movements very heavily. Today, my shoulders were really feeling the effects of the weighted dips, but by the end of my work day, I felt much, much better and decided to go back and do light weights--about 5 reps--for each movement, plus some deadlifts if I had the energy.
The chins and dips went great. I got a PR with 2 sets of 5 with 85 lbs on the chin and 95 lbs and 90 lbs on the dips (though that last set terminated at rep 4). I was very tired, but my conscience wouldn't let me leave the gym without trying some deadlifts which I haven't done in a couple of days. I worked up to triples with 315, but an intended double with 340 turned into a sloppy, leg-wobbling single as I ran out of steam. I lowered to 315 again, took a long rest and still only managed one with that. My glutes were starting to spasm a bit and my hams were feeling the strain. I figured a very light set--say 225--wouldn't hurt. I had gotten past the really dangerous part of my workout--the chins and dips--without crippling my shoulders, so I didn't fear some very light deadlifts. I should have feared them.
I remembered Pavel saying that people hurt themselves with light weights because they don't respect light weights. I kept that in mind and payed attention to form and stayed tight. Yet on the second deadlift with that 225, I felt something swell and rupture in my right glute. It didn't hurt enough for me to cry out and drop the weight, but I immediately set the thing down and sat on the floor, embarassed and shocked. I'd pushed myself too far with a back-off set of all things. I just wanted to practice the movement and get some blood in the area and now I was looking at a few days away from deadlifting at all. I managed to put strip the weights and put them back s-l-o-w-l-y and then limp out of the gym. It's a ten-block walk home and halfway there I was feeling a bit better and I even managed my usual sprint to the fourth floor, but as I sit here typing this, I can feel my glute tightening up. I will definitely feel this in the morning.
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 18 2006
|
|
You are setting yourself up for trouble -
Daily work on an exercise even while cycling weights means you have to pay attention to the routine - Continually pushing every 8-12 hours and "banging up" your shoulders is not smart.
Know when to say when - there are many days to lift - you miss too many when you push too far.
Heal fast and re-structure your routine
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
MrMyofibrillar: May 18 2006
|
|
I'm Healed!
|
|
Well almost. I was in acute pain last night after that deadlifting debacle. I considered not going in to work today. My job involves climbing poles and raising my right leg was causing a lot or pain in my glute. I can't really afford to take any time off right now, however, so in I went. By midday I was feeling much better and this evening I feel great. Not completely healed, but a lot better. I can fully articulate my hip and there's only a dull ache at the very extremes of my range.
Maybe I have some superhuman healing factor...or maybe the tweak wasn't as bad as the initial pain made it seem. Either way, I'm going to lay off of deadlifts for another few days and until all pain is gone.
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 18 2006
|
|
Glad to hear you are feeling better - it is wise to stay off the DLs for a few more days to heal up completely.
And then restructure your routine to allow for more recovery and listen to your body - you got lucky it would seem.
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
elarsen: May 23 2006
|
|
Double kettlebell swing advice
|
|
This may be one of those unanswerable questions but here it goes. Which would in theory be more beneficial to a distance runner, the clean and jerk or double kettlebell swings? I have a pair of 24's and have just started working both movements into my routines. I already do a lot of clean and presses so I was leaning more towards the heavy swings and possibly working up to double snatches.
At this point the presses, swings and snatches do not seem to cause as much leg heaviness on my runs as the clean and jerks do.
Just looking for opinions.
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 23 2006
|
|
elarsen,
the dbl KB swing will give you greater hip extension power and make your running stronger.
Stronger hips and hamstrings are a good thing.
Stretch the hip flexors as Thomas suggested.
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
Shawn M: May 23 2006
|
|
Curses to the Mirror...need help with single KB Military Press.......
|
|
I have been doing all my single KB presses in front of a mirror. I wanted to make sure my legs were locked and I did not lean and turn it into a side press.
Now when I try to MP without a mirror, I feel "disoriented"
Where do you look when you do a single military press.
I noticed Cotter seemed to look at the bell the whole time. I was wondering of turning the neck could in anyway decrease nerve enervation or increase the chance of neck strain.
Thanks for advise!!
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 23 2006
|
|
Go lighter for a couple of sessions and experiment - when not in front of the mirror - focus on the finish of the clean being crisp and loaded - ready for the press - during the press I find myself looking at the bell or slightly up but not at the bell.
If you hit the top of the clean loaded for the press - just press and see where your eyes want to go.
Brett
|
|
|
|
Question
|
Shawn M: May 23 2006
|
|
Curses to the Mirror...need help with single KB Military Press.......
|
|
I have been doing all my single KB presses in front of a mirror. I wanted to make sure my legs were locked and I did not lean and turn it into a side press.
Now when I try to MP without a mirror, I feel "disoriented"
Where do you look when you do a single military press.
I noticed Cotter seemed to look at the bell the whole time. I was wondering of turning the neck could in anyway decrease nerve enervation or increase the chance of neck strain.
Thanks for advise!!
|
|
Answer
|
BJones RKC: May 23 2006
|
|
Shawn,
You got it - simple doesn't mean easy! Powerlifters spend decades learning and refining their technique on Three lifts - there are only about 100,000 Kb lifts to groove. ;)
It is fun though!!
Brett
|
|
|